Explaining Public Support for Vigilantism > Part 1
Single Wave Study
General Information
Title
Part 1
Project Number
29.1
Abstract
This study concerns the first measuring moment with the questionnaire about support for vigilantism. Panel members were assigned at random to one of 12 groups. This group assignment determined which combination of fictitious news items was presented to the panel member. Ten groups were presented two news items. The first item described a criminal offence – of variable seriousness – followed by a number of questions about the people portrayed in the news item. The second news item reported the formal punishment imposed on the offender – of variable harshness – and that the victim, not satisfied with the sentence, had decided to impose his own punishment on the offender. The remaining two groups of respondents served as control groups, and they were presented just a single news item that reported the offense, the formal punishment and the vigilantism all at once. This was also followed by questions about the people portrayed in the news item.
Longitudinal Type
Single Wave Study
Begin date
07-09-2009
End date
30-09-2009
Note
Respondents in group 6 completed the questionnaire in November 2009, instead of September 2009.
Researcher
Haas, Nicole
Publisher
CentERdata
Copyright
© 2010 CentERdata
Funding Organization
CentERdata/MESS Project
DOI
https://doi.org/10.17026/dans-zhw-8frv
Datasets and documentation
View Documentation
Codebook, in English
Codebook, in Dutch (original version)
Data Files
English SPSS file
English STATA file
Word document containing extra long open answers in Dutch
Variables
Variable name | Variable Label | Variable Type |
---|---|---|
nomem_encr | Number of household member encrypted | preloaded |
be09a_m | Month in which questionnaire was completed | constructed |
be09a001 | Random distribution across twelve groups | constructed |
be09a002 | I think it’s awful what happened to Frank H./the girl | directly measured |
be09a003 | I feel sorry for Frank H./the girl | directly measured |
be09a004 | When I read this article, I realize that what happened to Frank H./the girl can also happen to me | directly measured |
be09a005 | I empathize with Frank H./the girl | directly measured |
be09a006 | The conduct shown by Ruben S. cannot be justified in any way | directly measured |
be09a007 | The conduct shown by Ruben S. is morally reprehensible | directly measured |
be09a008 | I am angry with Ruben S. | directly measured |
be09a009 | I feel sympathy for Ruben S. | directly measured |
be09a010 | The conduct shown by Ruben S. is understandable | directly measured |
be09a011 | I empathize with Ruben S. | directly measured |
be09a012 | Frank H./The girl is to blame for the collision/indecent assault | directly measured |
be09a013 | For the collision/indecent assault, Ruben S. (the driver)/Ruben S.... | directly measured |
be09a014 | For the collision/indecent assault, Frank H. (the cyclist)/the girl... | directly measured |
be09a015 | Frank H./The girl acted unwisely | directly measured |
be09a016 | Frank H./The girl acted irresponsibly | directly measured |
be09a017 | Frank H./The girl acted stupidly | directly measured |
be09a018 | Ruben S. should be prosecuted for what he has done | directly measured |
be09a019 | Ruben S. must be punished for his conduct | directly measured |
be09a020 | The authorities should let the collision/indecent assault go unpunished | directly measured |
be09a021 | Do you think that Ruben S.(the driver)/Ruben S. deserves punishment? | directly measured |
be09a022 | What kind of punishment, and how much of that punishment, do you think Ruben S. deserves? | directly measured |
be09a023 | How many demerits would you give to Ruben S.? | directly measured |
be09a024 | I think it’s awful that Ruben S. was manhandled | directly measured |
be09a025 | I feel sorry for Ruben S. | directly measured |
be09a026 | When I read this newspaper report, I realize that such an attack can also happen to me | directly measured |
be09a027 | I empathize with Ruben S. | directly measured |
be09a028 | The conduct shown by Frank H. cannot be justified in any way | directly measured |
be09a029 | The conduct shown by Frank H. is morally reprehensible | directly measured |
be09a030 | I am angry with Frank H. | directly measured |
be09a031 | I feel sympathy for Frank H. | directly measured |
be09a032 | The conduct shown by Frank H. is understandable | directly measured |
be09a033 | Frank H. was entirely right to manhandle Ruben S. | directly measured |
be09a034 | Frank H. is the victim in this situation, not the offender | directly measured |
be09a035 | Ruben S. has himself to blame for the attack | directly measured |
be09a036 | For the attack, Frank H. (the cyclist)/Frank H. (the father)... | directly measured |
be09a037 | For the attack, Ruben S. (the driver)/Ruben S.... | directly measured |
be09a038 | Ruben S. is stupid | directly measured |
be09a039 | Ruben S. is mentally disturbed | directly measured |
be09a040 | Ruben S. is bad | directly measured |
be09a041 | Frank H. should be prosecuted for what he has done | directly measured |
be09a042 | Frank H. must be punished for his conduct | directly measured |
be09a043 | The authorities should let the attack by Frank H. go unpunished | directly measured |
be09a044 | Do you think that Frank H. (the cyclist)/Frank H. deserves punishment for the attack? | directly measured |
be09a045 | What kind of punishment, and how much of that punishment, do you think Frank H. deserves? | directly measured |
be09a046 | How many demerits would you give to Frank H.? | directly measured |
be09a047 | Do you think that Ruben S.: | directly measured |
be09a048 | What kind of punishment, and how much of that punishment, do you think Ruben S. deserves? | directly measured |
be09a049 | How many demerits would you give to Ruben S.? | directly measured |
be09a050 | Do you think that Ruben S.: | directly measured |
be09a051 | What kind of punishment, and how much of that punishment, do you think Ruben S. deserves? | directly measured |
be09a052 | How many demerits would you give to Ruben S.? | directly measured |
be09a053 | Do you think that Ruben S. deserves punishment for the collision/indecent assault? | directly measured |
be09a054 | What kind of punishment, and how much of that punishment, do you think Ruben S. deserves? | directly measured |
be09a055 | How many demerits would you give to Ruben S.? | directly measured |
be09a056 | Do you ever visit the website www.nu.nl? | directly measured |
be09a057 | Was it difficult to answer the questions? | directly measured |
be09a058 | Were the questions sufficiently clear? | directly measured |
be09a059 | Did the questionnaire get you thinking about things? | directly measured |
be09a060 | Was it an interesting subject? | directly measured |
be09a061 | Did you enjoy answering the questions? | directly measured |
be09a062 | Starting date questionnaire | constructed |
be09a063 | Starting time questionnaire | constructed |
be09a064 | End date questionnaire | constructed |
be09a065 | End time questionnaire | constructed |
be09a066 | Duration in seconds | derived |
Questions
Questionnaire: Vigilantism, questionnaire 1
The questionnaire was originally conducted in Dutch.
Browse Vigilantism, questionnaire 1Response Information
Response Overview
Response:
Selected number of household members: 4384 (100.0%)
Non-response: 1681 (38.3%)
Response: 2703 (61.7%)
Complete: 2684 (61.2%)
Incomplete: 19 (0.4%)
Collection Events
Period
07-09-2009 to 30-09-2009
Sample
Random selection from panel members, age greater than or equal to 16
Collection Mode
internet survey
Fieldwork Note
a reminder was twice sent to non-respondents
Period
02-11-2009 to 25-11-2009
Sample
Respondents in group 6 completed the questionnaire in November 2009, instead of September 2009.
Collection Mode
internet survey
Fieldwork Note
a reminder was twice sent to non-respondents
Publications
Public Support for Vigilantism: An Experimental Study Journal of Experimental Criminology, 8, pp. 387-413; Haas, N.E.
et al.